Welcome to Nicky’s Pizza
At Nicky's Pizza, we pride ourselves on delivering authentic Italian flavors in a warm, family-friendly environment. Located in Agawam, Massachusetts, this beloved local eatery is renowned for its signature pizzas, crafted with care using fresh ingredients. Our casual atmosphere is perfect for families and groups, whether you're dining in or taking out after a day at Six Flags. Customers rave about our perfectly baked crust and savory sauces, with vegetarian options available to satisfy all palates. With a dedicated staff that treats every guest like family, Nicky's Pizza isn’t just a meal—it’s a memorable experience worth returning for.
-
1000 Main St Agawam, MA 01001 United States Hotline: (413) 786-9977
Welcome to Nicky’s Pizza, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Agawam, Massachusetts, where each slice tells a story of Italian culinary tradition. This family-owned eatery has carved a niche in the bustling food scene, offering not just pizza but a delightful array of Italian dishes that promise an unforgettable dining experience.
Nicky’s Pizza stands out for its commitment to quality and authenticity. Customers rave about the robust flavor profiles that define each dish, thanks to fresh ingredients and homemade recipes that transport diners straight to Italy. With a menu boasting a range of options—from classic pepperoni to gourmet vegetarian pizzas—there’s something to satisfy every palate.
- Pizza Perfection: The crust is consistently praised for its crispness, and the sauce has achieved cult status among regulars. Whether indulging in a giant slice or opting for their stuffed pasta, the quality is undeniable.
- Warm Atmosphere: Despite its casual decor, Nicky’s offers a welcoming vibe. Reviews highlight the friendly service, akin to dining at a friend's home, where staff are eager to personalize your experience and ensure your meal is perfect.
- Family Vibes: Nicky’s Pizza isn’t just a meal; it’s an experience. With family members actively involved in the day-to-day operations, you’ll feel the familial warmth from the moment you walk in.
- Convenience: With options for delivery and takeout, alongside on-site parking and outdoor seating, Nicky’s caters to both quick meals and leisurely family gatherings.
- Affordable Taste: Offering excellent dishes at moderate prices, it's an ideal spot for groups and families, making it a great value you won’t want to miss.
The glowing testimonials from diners, such as Bruce A. and Julie D., reaffirm Nicky’s dedication to not just satisfying appetites but also cultivating a loyal customer base. Each visit is not just for a meal; it’s an opportunity to savor quality dishes and connect with a community.
So, whether you find yourself after an exhilarating day at Six Flags or simply looking for a warm meal with loved ones, make Nicky’s Pizza your destination. Here, every slice is a testament to the rich Italian heritage and genuine hospitality that make this restaurant a beloved fixture in Agawam.
For those ready to taste the magic, Nicky’s Pizza awaits at 1000 Main St, Agawam, MA 01001. You can also get in touch at (413) 786-9977. Your next favorite pizza experience is just a call away!
There are only a few food options in this part of Agawam. Friendly service. Mostly a take out place but there is limited seating to eat in.
This pizza is amazing! Stopped here after Six Flags on our way back to NY. Great find and a go-to for us stop every time! Staff are very nice and we appreciated them making us up some additional pepperoni and fresh mushroom slices at the last minute! Pizza was perfectly crusty and the sauce was delicious!
Great, small informal family run Italian eatery. Excellent fresh food. Cash only! Pizza with great dough in multiple sizes. Excellent stuffed pasta and soups.
Never in a million years if you told me I'd find the hands down the best slice of pizza I've had in my life at a random town in Massachusetts after attending six flags theme park, I would've said you're insane... I've been around the world due to my work and ate a lot of pizza. This place nailed every aspect of a good slice. Crisp bottom, seasoned sauce, great meat/veg (I had the combo), crispy crust and great cheese!!!! The slice was GIANT too. Well worth your money and they actually give a damn about the food. Walking into the place it is definitely that local mom and pop feel. You can tell people in the community there know them and love the food too. Felt like a great casual atmosphere and the owner was great and so was the staff. If you're passing through EAT the pizza here, you won't regret it!!! Can't speak for other aspects of the menu but being from another state if I'm ever near this place, I'm coming back no questions asked!!!
Love the food. Huge menu of every Italian dish you can think of. Delicious.... always a pleasure to go to Nicky's. Great services. Staff always is so pleasant in their greeting. An important and well loved restaurant in Agawam.
There are a lot of crappy pizza places with tiny slices out there. Nicky's is not one of those places. They offer flavorful pies that will satisfy the pickiest pizza connoisseur. They have large slices available. One slice is a meal. Staff advised us we only needed one! Friendly staff delivered to our table. Nicky does exist. He was in the house. It's not just a name!
ZThe pizza is absolutely delicious here. I like the combo pizza , so if you're in the area give them a try you will enjoy the food.
Nicky's makes great pizza. We place an order for a bar/lounge in Agawam every Friday night. Place is usually crowded which means every piece of 2 party size pizzas are gone...quickly. Highly recommend this place. Tuffi
OKAY, so the five stars wouldn't be about ambiance. But it's about EVERYTHING ELSE that is more important! Give me tablecloths and fine china with moderately good food, and I will RUN to Nicky's Pizza every time, even with their vintage tables and modest decor. It's clean and comfortable enough. So... First of all, the food is incredibly delicious and memorble. The pizza sauce is so amazing I want to go back for all of their pasta dishes. Everything is homemade, and I think they must be hiding an Italian grandmother back there somewhere, cooking up an authentic savory storm. The crust is fabulous, including their cauliflower crust. No pizza in the area even comes close to being this good on quality products (NO CANOLA EVER), taste, and preparation. Second, we tried the homemade clam chowder. Wow. If this is the example of New England chowder, it ROCKS. Third, this place gives family-owned and family-run a good name. Nicky hires his family. Tony, his son, and the spokesperson at the counter, couldn't be friendlier or more efficient. You feel like family even as a customer. He will chat, but his eye is always scanning, making sure every order is perfect. And by the time he introduced me to Giani, Pat, Enzo and problably someone i missed (maybe that grandmother), I was sure it was a happy family. It says something about a man whose relatives want to work with him. We haven't indulged in fried pickles, poutain, fried dough, or much else--but we will. I don't know why, other than the 8 mile drive, I don't go here more, but I will now that I have re-visited and recalled how good it all is--and very affordable! They only deliver in Agawam and Feeding Hills--not Enfield sadly, and they only take cash, so we imagine that is one reason their prices have stayed so low. Try Nicky's Pizza. It's a hands-down winner.